Restaurant Review

Pepperoncini

Description

Pepperoncini is a neighborhood Italian restaurant on South Eagle Road in Havertown. It’s the kind of spot you can keep in mind for a family dinner, a date night, or a chance to catch up with friends. The menu features Italian favorites and weekly specials. The restaurant also has a Sunday dinner called “Red Gravy Sunday,” a nod to the Italian tradition of gathering around the table for a meal. On nights when you’d rather eat at home, Pepperoncini offers family-style takeout, too.

Our Visit

Restaurant Snapshot

📍 Location

25 S. Eagle Road Havertown, PA 19083

🍽️ Cuisine

American, Italian, etc.

💲 Price Range

$$–$$$ | About $25–$45 per person for a main dish

❤️ Best For

Family dinner, date night

What we Ordered

Fried Calamari

Marinara, fresh lemon basil aioli

Chicken Parm

Pan fried cutlets, homemade marinara, provolone, choice of Spaghetti or Rigatoni.

Veal Pepperoncini

Sauteed with lump crab meat, olives, diced tomato, pepperoncini peppers, herbs in a white wine sauce over your choice of Spaghetti or Rigatoni.

Our Experience

 

A Rainy Night at Pepperoncini

We’d heard great things about Pepperoncini, so on a rainy Saturday in October, we made it a family night out. The fall harvest decorations caught our eye as soon as we arrived. They made the entrance feel warm and cozy on a wet night.

We had our choice of sitting downstairs near the bar or heading upstairs to the more formal dining room. We chose upstairs and got a table by the window, where we could watch the rain as we settled in.

Drinks

Our friendly waitress welcomed us and took our drink orders. I went with my usual hazy IPA, and the kids stuck with their Shirley Temples. Lauren ordered an espresso martini and called it one of the best she’s ever had.

Appetizers and Salad

We started with Pepperoncini’s take on Shrimp Lejon, a special made with shrimp wrapped in thin slices of prosciutto. I thought it was delicious, and my son made quick work of it. We also ordered crispy calamari, one of our usual picks. Lauren and I are picky about calamari, and we both put Pepperoncini’s in our top three.

We always like to split a Caesar salad. For us, a good one needs dressing with plenty of flavor, lettuce that snaps when you bite into it, and crunchy homemade croutons. Pepperoncini got all three right.

Main Dishes

Lauren ordered her usual chicken parm and asked for blush sauce in place of the red sauce. The kitchen made the swap at no extra charge. She got a generous serving of chicken and a side of pasta she really enjoyed.

I ordered the Veal Pepperoncini. It came over pasta with lump crab meat, olives, diced tomatoes, herbs, and pepperoncini peppers in a white wine sauce. The peppers gave each bite a bright, tangy kick. The veal was so tender I could cut it with my fork.

My son kept it simple with a chicken Caesar salad. My daughter’s pasta came with one huge meatball right on top. It was tender and packed with flavor, and she already knows what she’s ordering next time.

Dessert

By the time we finished dinner, we were too full for dessert. Next time, we’ll save room.

Would we go back

hbdiwbdchdjdejdjbcbjebcjbedbudbcuecdbjucbecbjcejbcjjecbjebjcejcbjecbejcbejcbcjejbecjecbjejecbjecjbecbcjcbjjebcjbc

Havertown Neighbors rating

How it Scored

Havertown Neighbors Restaurant Rating

4.0/5
Overall Rating
Food
Service
Atmosphere
Value
Preview only: click stars to test ratings. Save final ratings in the code below.

Food